Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Loades of History, Mike Loades's avatar

Great piece. I am fascinated by our evolving relationship with dogs - I wrote a book about it :) - but I love the focus in this piece about their importance to our mental and physical well-being. I relate to all you say here. They are also a great reminder to us wordy bods that there are many layers of communication beyond words. Right - off to take my two for a walk now - in silence.

Phillippa Law's avatar

Fantastic myth-busting article!

I really enjoyed reading and learning from it.

I wondered whether you might consider moving away from the term “domestication” when referring to dogs.

As you pointed out later in the piece, dogs were not domesticated in the traditional sense of deliberate human control and selective breeding.

Rather, they appear to have co-evolved alongside humans, beginning with wolves that scavenged near human settlements and gradually transitioning into proto-dogs, village dogs, and eventually the genetically distinct domestic dogs we know today. This process occurred over tens of thousands of years, largely driven by natural and social selection rather than intentional human design.

It’s also worth remembering that, until relatively recently, free-roaming dogs were a normal and accepted part of human settlements. The concepts of the “stray dog” and organised dog catching only invented in the late 19th and early 20th centuries in efforts to regulate and eradicate free-living dog populations. Before that, village, town, and city dogs, both owned and unowned, existed openly as part of the social and ecological fabric of human communities. In many parts of the world, this remained common well into the late 20th century. Its odd they way we forget such major social change so quickly dont you think?

Sorry for rambling on keep up the good work.

7 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?